John Malkovich. Sam Rockwell. Martin McDonagh. The Best Cheese*.
DIRECTED BY MARTIN MCDONAGH/2026

When my wife, seated next to me in the movie theater, first saw the trailer for Martin McDonagh‘s Wild Horse Nine, she leaned over and said, “It’s the actor pairing I didn’t know I needed!” She nailed it that McDonagh had nailed it. John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell riffing off of each other for an entire film? Yes please! They say casting is 80% of the success factor in any given film. It’s rare that a trailer confidently confirms that theory, but with Steve Buscemi, Tom Waits, and Parker Posey also on board, Wild Horse Nine was safely looking like the most satisfying cast list since Seven Psychopaths… another Martin McDonagh joint.
So what about that pesky other 20%? Don’t worry, McDonagh’s still got it. In fact, he’s topped himself. As great as his other four movies may be, Wild Horse Nine leaves nothing on the table. Seeing it at Alamo Drafthouse meant we were honored to get one of their best pre-show custom reels that I’ve ever seen. More than just a dorky hepcat montage of one of the actors or worse, a bunch of random YouTube-sourced nonsense, we got a truly contextualizing reel demonstrating the connective themes of strained faith and friendships amid his trademark sparky dialogue and carefully planted heartbreak. This has made me determined to reexamine the playwright/filmmaker’s two movies I have not claimed to love, In Bruge and Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri. Stay tuned for whenever I get around to them.

Early word has been that it might be Malkovich’s year to win a Best Actor Oscar. Justified. Playing Chris, a terminally ill CIA operative tasked with destabilizing Chile’s new left-wing government (a horrendous and shameful bit of actual history) in 1973, Malkovich organically leaves no potent character bit unpacked. Chris is at turns quirky, comedic, remorseful, resigned, and so much more. He’s killed and killed and killed at home and abroad for all manner of assignments in his decades as a spook. For far too long, the only solutions he’s known involves shooting people. We know that not from any flashbacks or montages, but simply because when Malkovich and the also pitch-perfect Rockwell chat about it, we believe them. 100%.
Wild Horse Nine also nails the needledrops (not overbearing but reliably poignant) within its slowly mounting tensions and perfect volleys of perfect dialogue (so often hilariously profane). That it all exudes, by virtue of its locations (most of which is on majestic Easter Island), the filmmaker’s clear fascination with out-the-way places that hold a certain ancient mysteriousness. Alluring places that might even be sacred. Chris demands that he and Lee (Rockwell) jaunt from Chile to Easter Island for week, as he really wants to see “the big heads” before he kicks off for good. Having been working closely long enough to consider each other as good of friends as anyone in their line of work is likely to ever have, Lee obliges. As we go, it becomes clear that Chris doesn’t necessarily intend to go back to Chile. And he expects Lee to help him. But can he really trust Lee? Their boss, a sweaty slimy Steve Buscemi at his Steve Buscemi-est, doesn’t like any of this running off. He doesn’t like that Chris is developing a propensity for blabbing top secret stuff to randos, and that Chris is talking about writing his memoirs (!!) detailing a life of things that no one is supposed to know about.

That Chris, as played by Malkovich, is unreliable and unpredictable on multiple levels makes him one of the most complex and compelling movie characters maybe of all time. Is what he says an outrageous truth of a man in decline and losing his filter, or a CIA-trained liar lying? His memory is going, and there’s things related to past covert actions- some such actions as notorious as they get- that only he knows. He’s affected history, but to him it’s all shruggy b.s. He forgets things, he manipulates those he’s closest to, he’s both brutally honest and full of horsecrap at the same time. He’s packing heat and he might have a bomb. He’s fixated on a pair of leftist college girls that a man of his age and condition has no chance with, but why let the truth get in the way of a good pursuit? And yes, eventually, things can’t help but get violent.
All this to say, McDonagh‘s really got something here. To paraphrase the late Manny Farber in discussing Jean-Luc Godard, already McDonagh has a zoo that includes a gentle deer (Three Billboards), a miniature donkey (The Banshees of Inisherin), at least nine wild horses (this), and whatever spirit animals there may be for his other two films. What wild, wildlife can follow, and where will we be taken to find it?
* This is not a cheesy movie. – ZF Bureau Chief