Beware of the Big Orange Freak, Kids!

DIRECTED BY CASPER KELLY/2026

We got what we tuned in for, but also we didn’t.  

Buddy
 fulfills its surface-level promise of being about a homicidal children’s show character: Buddy, from “Buddy”, circa 1999, wherein a small group of intensionally diverse children (Delaney Quinn, Caleb “C.J.” Williams, Madison Skyy Polan, and a few others who rotate in and out) live in a small, pastel saccharine slice of suburbia with a Chuck E. Cheese-esque a talking mailbox (Mr. Mailbox, voiced by Eric Bauza), an alive bespectacled couch (Couchy), an overly-involved pink backpack (Strappy, voiced by Patton Oswalt), a friendly mailman, an always on-call nurse, etc.  

When their squeaky-clean existence of funny dances and learning life lessons begins to be revealed to actually be about imposing conformity upon the young, Buddy (voiced by Keegan-Michael Key)- an adult-sized rotund orange furry unicorn- lashes out.  A kid who’d rather read a science fiction novel than go to a dance party ominously vanishes.  The other kids find his sci-fi novel splatted with what might be blood discarded in Trashy the trash can.  But every episode ends with a freeze-frame of the kids hugging Buddy their unicorn pal, and this one must be no different.

A new episode begins.  The plot thickens, even as we stay firmly in 4×3-aspect-ratio kids’ TV land.  Buddy insists that any deviance from doing what he says does the worst thing possible: it hurts his feelings.  For me, I was thinking about WandaVision, another clever venture into a TV land where all is not well, and it’s only a matter of time before the facade gives way to the meta.  And sure enough, it does.  And unlike WandaVision, this is where Buddy starts to fall apart.

Inevitably, the aggressively innocuous TV world of “Buddy” bleeds into our world.  Why?  I dunno.  We meet a mom (Cristin Milioti) who’s husband doesn’t show any real compassion when she freaks out over an empty chair at their table.  We do learn what the deal is with that, but not why.  And boy oh boy do the “Why?s” pile up.  

The final third of Buddy is all about dangling one frustrating unexplained detail after another, falling right into that all-too-familiar trap of setting up more such “mascot horror” sequels rather than getting its house in order in the here and now.  If this is a matter where we, the viewers, need to put on our magic metaphor-decoding shoes, that needs to be clearer.  Because when I look at the big gross orange self-obsessed overlording unicorn with a hair-trigger temper who demands loyalty, my mind goes to only one guy.  (One guess which U.S. leader I’m referring to).  Yet, in interviews, creators of Buddy have denied any such intended read.  

So, what are we doing, guys??  Are we telling a story, or just dancing around?